CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article On the Beat: The Arbit... (01/19)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/18)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/23)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Future Shock: Bang for... (01/19)

January 19, 2012

Transaction Analysis

A Tale of Four Starters

by Ben Lindbergh

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

Subscribe for $4.95 per month
Recurring subscription - cancel anytime.

a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Purchase a $39.95 gift subscription
a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.


American League
National League

Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Signed RHP Bartolo Colon to a one-year, $2 million deal. [1/15]

Last March, I wrote a piece for BP and ESPN gauging Colon’s chances for success after missing a year at an advanced age. Spoiler: I didn’t think they were all that good, even though he was coming off strong performances in winter ball and spring training. In my defense, I wasn’t the only one who was spectacularly wrong—we didn’t even put him in the annual.

Of course, we didn’t know until May that Colon had undergone an experimental stem cell procedure in the Dominican Republic, which in retrospect turned out to be important information. Even if that news had come to light earlier, I probably wouldn’t have changed my tune, since “experimental stem cell procedure in the Dominican Republic” doesn’t inspire much confidence until you’ve seen the results. Colon was entering his age-38 season and hadn’t been simultaneously healthy and effective for several seasons. The safe bet was that he’d be unhealthy and ineffective again.

The safe bet was wrong. Colon pitched 164 1/3 innings (the most he’d managed since his 2005 Cy Young season) with an ERA below league-average and a FIP to match, giving the Yankees a lot of bang for their 900,000 bucks. His fastball averaged around 92 mph throughout the season, and he struck out his highest percentage of opposing batters since 2001, all while throwing fastballs (both four-seam and two-seam) almost exclusively. He did break down eventually, spending 20 days on the DL with a left hamstring strain from mid-June through early July and pitching relatively poorly thereafter, but he was still worth over two wins, making him the most valuable non-Sabathia starter in a thin Yankees rotation.

We’ve seen pitchers who were less effective last season sign for more than Colon this winter, which isn’t surprising. Signing Colon is the equivalent of signing lightning after it strikes for the first time. Unless he’s discovered an even more impressive experimental procedure this winter, he’ll enter next season a year older, and likely no lighter, than he entered last season. That, coupled with his underwhelming end to 2011, explains why he wasn’t signed until now. But there’s another reason for buyers to beware that has nothing to do with his birth date or body.

Remember that impressive strikeout percentage? In one sense, it may have been less impressive than it appeared. Over half of Colon’s strikeouts were called; among other pitchers with at least 50 IP last season, only Vance Worley could say the same. Colon recorded the ninth-lowest swinging-strike rate among pitchers with at least 2,000 deliveries. So what’s the problem? A strikeout is a strikeout, right? Well, yes, in a retrospective sense. But swinging strike rate is a better predictor of future strikeout rate than called strike rate, so the fact that so many of Colon’s Ks were called might not bode well for his chances of repeating his 2011 performance—especially since he’ll be throwing to an average framing catcher in Kurt Suzuki instead of an excellent one like Russell Martin.*

*It's official: I’ve now linked to Mike Fast’s framing article enough times that I know the URL by heart.

Still, stranger things have happened than Colon pitching well in 2012—Colon pitching well in 2011, for instance. With a winter of rest, a bigger ballpark, and—if he knows what’s good for him—another helping of stem cells, he could be capable of giving the A’s another good half-season before fatigue sets in and another DL stint inevitably follows, which would make him worth his salary. Until then, he’ll be the only member of the A’s rotation over 28, let alone 38, as Oakland attempts to field a watchable team while it rebuilds.

The deal has been pending a physical for a few days now, but it should become official once the A’s find a doctor willing to see Colon with his shirt off.

Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Signed RHP Yu Darvish to a six-year, $60 million contract. [1/18]

We—and by “we,” I mean Kevin Goldstein, who knows much more about Yu Darvish than I do—have already told you what we (and sources inside the game) think Yu Darvish will be, as well as what his acquisition might mean for the Rangers. The only thing we haven’t been able to tell you is what he’ll cost. And now we know that, too.

It came down to the wire, as it always does,* but the Rangers reached an agreement to pay Darvish $60 million over the next six years, which—if all goes well—will give him a shot at an even bigger contract after his age-31 season. Of course, the Rangers also have to give $51.7 million to the Hokkaido Nippon Ham Fighters, Darvish’s former team, which brings the total cost to Texas up to $111.7 million. If you spread that over six years (which the Rangers can’t do, since they have to pay the posting fee now—possibly with interest, if there’s a loan involved), it works out to $18.6 million. Here’s a complete list of pitchers who earned more last season than the Rangers will be paying for the privilege of playing Darvish in 2012:

  1. CC Sabathia (Yankees)
  2. Johan Santana (Mets)
  3. Carlos Zambrano (Cubs)

One of those pitchers didn’t make a single major-league appearance in 2011, and one of them pitched poorly for a while before deciding that he’d rather stop pitching entirely. Darvish is expected to pitch, possibly for the whole season, so compared to those other teams, the Rangers are getting a good deal.

I’m being a bit facetious, but the fact that two of those three teams got almost no return on their large pitcher investments last season goes to show how risky large pitcher investments can be. Still, $18.6 seems like a reasonable range for a 25-year-old whom most teams believe has ace potential with a high probability of being at least a number-two type, and whom the Rangers clearly preferred to the over-30 C.J. Wilson, who got five/$75.

If there’s any victim here, it’s Darvish, who gets jobbed financially by the posting process. No team would be willing to pay that $51.7 million fee—which he won’t see a penny of—on top of an appropriate salary, so instead, he’ll make much less than Mark Buehrle money. That's significantly below-market value for a player with his background and ability, even if it does represent a raise over his roughly $6 million earnings last season.

*When does a baseball transaction not come down to the wire? Trade deadline. Draft signing deadline. It’s always the same. Whatever and whenever the deadline is, the signing happens a few minutes before it. Sometimes it happens a few minutes after it, and everything works out anyway. It’s like every member of Major League Baseball has senioritis and is taking the season pass/fail.

Nolan Ryan: Jon, have you started working on that Yu Darvish contract yet?
Jon Daniels: Not yet. The deadline isn’t for weeks.
Nolan Ryan: Wouldn’t it be good to get an early start?
Jon Daniels: I’m a GM. I have a lot of stuff to do.
Nolan Ryan: I’m just say—
Jon Daniels: I knooooow. Goddd. I’ll do it, okay?
[Four weeks later]
Nolan Ryan: The deadline is five minutes from now. Did we sign Yu Darvish yet?
Nolan Ryan: /Has heart attack, takes Advil

Okay, so maybe it’s not procrastination. It’s negotiation. But still, if I’d procrastinegotiated that much while I was in grade school, I would’ve been grounded. Which I probably wouldn’t have minded that much, since it would’ve given me more time to read Arthur C. Clarke books or something. But that’s all in the past. Now I spend my free time writing fake dialogues between baseball executives.

Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Signed LHP Joe Saunders to a one-year, $6 million contract. [1/18]

Saunders made $5.5 million for the Diamondbacks last season. Despite his 12-13 record, his 3.69 ERA and 212 innings pitched put him in line for a raise to the $8-9 million range in his final year of arbitration. The D-Backs weren’t willing to pay that, but they were willing to talk multi-year deal, reportedly offering him two years and $12 million. Saunders countered at three years and $27 million, essentially asking the team to commit to a long-term contract without any discount on his expected arbitration earnings. Arizona understandably declined and, in one of the winter’s most predictable moves, non-tendered him.

Saunders will still end up with the Snakes, but he’ll have to settle for one measly year at a rate that earlier this offseason made him turn up his nose at two. That’s a win for Kevin Towers, even if the spoils aren’t especially exciting. Saunders at $6 million isn’t a steal, but it is at or below the going rate for a league-average pitcher. That’s exactly what Saunders is, though you wouldn’t know it from his FIP, which insists that he’s considerably worse than that. The secret to his ability to outperform his peripherals is an exceptional talent for inducing double plays, perhaps partially as a result of his quick pace.

Saunders won’t finish with an ERA below 4.00 again without another low BABIP or a further decline in league-wide offense, but his presence will allow the Diamondbacks to be patient with Trevor Bauer without blocking any prospects beyond 2012. If he eats innings that might otherwise have gone to Barry Enright, he’ll be worth a win or two. A win or two is worth a lot where the Diamondbacks are on the win curve, so they were probably right to bring him back on their own contractual terms. The only question is whether they could have gotten just as much out of Wade Miley for much less. One could wonder the same about their decision to displace Gerardo Parra with Jason Kubel earlier this offseason. There’s something to be said for making sure a win-now team wins now, but paying for redundant production causes problems in the long run.

Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Signed LHP Jamie Moyer to a minor-league contract with an invitation to spring training. [1/18]

If you’re between 40 and 50 and a baseball fan, you now have permission to feel young again.

When writing about Jamie Moyer, it’s customary to start off with a factoid that conveys some sense of how old he is. For example, I could name some long-forgotten players Moyer faced. I could count how many current Rockies hadn’t been born when Moyer debuted in the majors. I could mention that I hadn’t been born when Moyer debuted in the majors. (Neither had Yu Darvish, for that matter) But I’m not going to do that (any more than I just did, at least). We all get the point. Jamie Moyer is old, but he’s still clinging to his place in a young man’s game, and that’s something to be celebrated.

Watching major-league players in their primes thrills us, inspires us, and makes us want to see more. Watching Moyer does all of those things, but for different reasons. It’s not the same sort of thrilling to watch a 40-something man’s fastball barely break 80 as it is to see Aroldis Chapman touch triple digits, Mike Stanton hit a deep drive, or Peter Bourjos cross half an outfield to come up with a catch. But to see him barely break 80 on a major-league mound, somehow surviving in the same games as ultra-athletic men half his age, makes us all feel a better about where we’ll be at age 49 and beyond.

The thing that strikes me about Moyer’s statistical record is how little black ink there is. In 24 seasons and over 4,000 innings, Moyer has led his league only three times, in three separate categories. Two of those times were for bad things: in 1987, he led the NL with 114 earned runs, and in 2004, he led the AL with 44 long balls. The only time he was the best at something was in 1996, when he barely qualified for the AL lead in winning percentage, going 13-3 in 160 2/3 innings. He made an All-Star team only once, at age 40. He’ll finish with an ERA+ at or around 100. He managed a couple consecutive four-plus-win seasons in the late-1990s, but they’re almost buried under an avalanche of ones, twos, and threes. He was a good pitcher for a very long time, but the only thing he’s truly excelled at is staying employed, which is remarkable in its own right.

We all would’ve preferred to see Moyer land somewhere better-suited to a soft-tossing lefty, like Safeco, where he spent his last several years in Seattle, or Petco, where he could avoid the DH. Coors is no place for his kind (or, for that matter, for most of the Rockies’ new arms). He was last a valuable pitcher in 2008, he didn’t pitch last season, and he’s so ancient that aging curves can no longer tell us what he might be projected to do—he’s extending the aging curve as he goes.

This move has no playoff implications. If Moyer manages to make the team, he’ll be keeping a rotation spot warm for a much younger, more talented pitcher, and he likely won’t last long. The only reason to expect signing Moyer to succeed is that it’s always worked before, and at some point, entropy always wins. But that’s all in the future. Jamie Moyer has an invitation to spring training. For another few months, we can pretend that we won’t get old either.

Ben Lindbergh is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Ben's other articles. You can contact Ben by clicking here

Related Content:  Jamie Moyer,  The Who,  Jon Daniels,  Joe Saunders

23 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links


I can't help but think Darvish will be better than most sources are letting on, except for BP with your last article on Yu, comparing him to guys like Greinke and Garza instead of the oft-thrown out Zimmermann comp, which I think doesn't do his abilities justice.

I think people are particularly bearish on the K Rate. ZIPS projected him for under 170 Ks annually, when even Dice-K, who was an inferior strikeout pitcher in Japan, notched over 200 Ks in a "mediocre" first season. Darvish should be able to log a ton of innings, being stronger and more durable, so his win potential and Ks should also be raised for that.

Anyway, what do you project for him, off the top of your head?

Jan 19, 2012 00:22 AM
rating: 2
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

I'm not sure a projection off the top of my head would have any value. In fact, I'm pretty sure it wouldn't. We're working on PECOTA projections for Darvish and Cespedes, among other foreign imports.

Jan 19, 2012 07:22 AM

Okay, I am looking forward to that projection :)

Jan 19, 2012 08:00 AM
rating: 2
Richard Bergstrom

I thought there was a Davenport translation for Japanese leagues to the majors.

That being said, one article I read discussed Yu just started practicing with a MLB baseball instead of a Japanese baseball (yep, there are differences), and that could be a little bit disconcerting.

Also, there are reports he can opt out of the sixth year if he does well in Cy Young voting.

Jan 19, 2012 12:20 PM
rating: 0
BP staff member Dave Pease
BP staff

We're working on those translations now... more on them soon.

Jan 19, 2012 14:46 PM

Can we anticipate not reading about Moyer in this Year's annual (coming soon to a book-selling franchise near you!)?

Jan 19, 2012 04:53 AM
rating: 0
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

I believe that's the case--he's not in the Phillies chapter, and I don't know where else he could be. Let's hope we're kicking ourselves for it next winter.

Jan 19, 2012 07:20 AM

Maybe in future editions there can be a section for unsigned players that sat out the year?

Jan 19, 2012 14:31 PM
rating: 2
Richard Bergstrom

As I recall, it's an issue with space though some (myself) included have said we wouldn't mind paying a bit more for more players and a return of some of the "back-of-the-book" essays.

Jan 19, 2012 20:22 PM
rating: 0

"The deal has been pending a physical for a few days now, but it should become official once the A’s find a doctor willing to see Colon with his shirt off."

LOL! (and I'm very careful to use that initialism only in its literal sense)

Good stuff.

Jan 19, 2012 08:19 AM
rating: 3
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

Thanks. By the way, late-breaking "Jamie Moyer is old" fact I just discovered: on the day Yu Darvish was born, Moyer pitched a complete game shutout against the Expos.

Jan 19, 2012 08:24 AM

That's one of the best random facts ever

Jan 19, 2012 10:25 AM
rating: 7

Seriously?? Blaming the team for the negotiations going down to the wire?? You're kidding right. So when the agent come sin with a preposterous demand just cave and give it to him??

In baseball it takes two to procrastinate and the player's agent is every much to blame as the team. And if the agent is Scott Boras it is always the agents fault.

Jan 19, 2012 08:36 AM
rating: -3
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

Those were jokes! I don't blame anyone, or think that anyone's actually procrastinating. Both teams and players are perfectly entitled to do deals right before the deadline.

Jan 19, 2012 08:40 AM

Hahahaha! Boomer, you should go find the Wezen-Ball post on The Kids in the Hall from a few days ago. I think you'd make a wonderful Foley-esque vaudevillian.

Jan 19, 2012 11:41 AM
rating: 3


How in the world could you ever refer to the Yankees' rotation as thin??? It may not have been very good, but with both CC and Colon, it was definitely not thin.

Jan 19, 2012 09:49 AM
rating: 10
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

Maybe I missed a good joke opportunity there. On the other hand, too easy.

Jan 19, 2012 11:52 AM
Richard Bergstrom

Too easy? That's the Red Sox rotation.

*pops the top on another beer*

Jan 19, 2012 12:21 PM
rating: 5

I hope Moyer never retires as he is the last remaining player older than I am (by 4 months).

Jan 19, 2012 12:45 PM
rating: 1

As of now Moyer and Omar Vizquel are the only players still active the year I started watching baseball and Vizquel was a rookie.

Jan 19, 2012 16:11 PM
rating: 0

As a fellow 49 year old, I cheer for Jamie Moyer every day. :-)

Jan 19, 2012 14:24 PM
rating: 0

I'm amazed that Darvish doesn't simply punt back to NPB for one more year and then hit MLB free agency next offseason as a 26-year-old, utterly unrestricted free agent ace. He'd double his initial payday, and still have a go at another mega-contract later (assuming he signed a five-year deal upon coming over). The math seems easy to me.

Jan 19, 2012 14:26 PM
rating: 1

I don't think he would have been a free agent until 2014 though.

Jan 20, 2012 05:18 AM
rating: 0
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Premium Article On the Beat: The Arbit... (01/19)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/18)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/23)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Future Shock: Bang for... (01/19)

Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Spring Shuffling
Every Team's Moneyball: Cincinnati Reds: Go ...
Every Team's Moneyball: Chicago White Sox: T...
Premium Article Some Projection Left: The Moran Mystery
Notes from the Field: Seven Days and 32 Pros...
Spring Training Notebook: Cactus League
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Demise of the Two-Out Rally

Premium Article Future Shock: Indians Top 11 Prospects
Premium Article Future Shock: Bang for the Buck
Premium Article On the Beat: The Arbitration Preview Edition
Premium Article The Keeper Reaper: Starting Pitchers for 1/1...
The BP Wayback Machine: Roger Abrams

2012-01-24 - Overthinking It: The Player Popularity Test
2012-01-23 - Premium Article Collateral Damage: Rounding Up the Usual Sus...
2012-01-20 - Premium Article Collateral Damage: Rounding Up the Usual Sus...
2012-01-19 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: A Tale of Four Starter...
2012-01-17 - Overthinking It: Jorge Posada, the Hall of F...
2012-01-17 - BP Unfiltered: Visualizing Our Jack Morris F...
2012-01-16 - Premium Article Collateral Damage: The Latest Offseason Surg...

2012-01-26 - Transaction Analysis: AL on the Rise, and Ex...
2012-01-25 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: The New Prince of Moto...
2012-01-23 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Pena's Power Returns t...
2012-01-19 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: A Tale of Four Starter...
2012-01-18 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: A-nother Oakland Outfi...
2012-01-16 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Jesus the Mariner
2012-01-12 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Off-Brand Bargains