CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit Lis... (08/13)
<< Previous Column
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Oth... (08/11)
Next Column >>
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Sta... (08/15)
Next Article >>
Premium Article The Call-Up: Rymer Lir... (08/13)

August 13, 2014

Fantasy Freestyle

Setting Expectations on Superstars

by J.P. Breen

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

Subscribe for $4.95 per month
Recurring subscription - cancel anytime.

a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Purchase a $39.95 gift subscription
a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

“He’s just a name-brand at this point. He’s not as good as people think. At this point, people are blinded by previous performance, rather than current or future performance.”

My buddy, Drew, leaned forward and smiled as he crossed off Tom Brady’s name from our pre-draft ranking sheet. Drew and I have co-owned a fantasy football team for years. He’s the brains of the operation. I’m along for the ride because it makes me more interested in the NFL than I otherwise would be, but Drew spent the better part of two months preaching to me that Tom Brady was no longer the quarterback everyone had grown accustomed to over the past decade. We had him as the no. 8 QB in our pre-draft rankings and it’s not difficult to imagine the smug look on our faces as we watched Brady go as the third-overall QB in the second round.

Sure enough, Brady finished the season as the 13th-best fantasy quarterback in ESPN leagues. Drew shot text messages my way every weekend, gloating about the accuracy of his prediction. Ultimately, his take was nails. People were paying for the name brand. Expectations weren’t in line with reality; thus, many fantasy football owners paid the price throughout the season.

Properly leveling expectations once something changes in the fantasy profile is important across the board, but when it comes to superstar players and guys who will be drafted in the first two or three rounds of the draft, it becomes paramount. You can’t miss atop the draft. It’s a chore to recover that lost production. Either the remainder of the draft must be spectacular or you have to be a waiver-wire magician.

It’s something that resonated with me heading into the 2014 fantasy baseball season. In re-draft leagues, I shied away from players who had significant changes in overall profile, whether it be difficult ballparks, injuries, uncharacteristic breakout seasons, etc. I prioritized “sure things” in the first few rounds.

Such a hands-off approach helped me avoid guys like Joey Votto, Chris Davis, Dustin Pedroia, Alex Rios, and Carlos Gonzalez. However, it also meant that I carelessly discarded players such as Ian Kinsler and Robinson Cano. Over four months into the season, though, we can perhaps start to recalibrate and properly level expectations for some of the players we may have been nervous to draft prior to the season. I want to focus on two in this space.

OF Ryan Braun, Milwaukee Brewers
Cynics want to point to the PED scandal, but let’s be honest. The largest concern for Braun is his troublesome thumb injury. He’s dealing with a significant nerve issue in his thumb, and here’s what he had to say about it earlier in the season:

"The analogy is if you touch a hot stove, no matter how badly you want to keep your hand there, the natural reaction will be to take your hand off it. That's kind of what happens every time I make contact, when it gets bad. No matter what I want to do or try to do, I can't keep two hands on the bat.”


"My whole thumb was numb. But we're always dealing with little things with our hands, whether you get jammed or you hit it off the end of the bat. Your hand hurts but you just assume it will go away after a couple of days. That's what I was hoping would occur, but it didn't and still hasn't."


"The challenge with this is that I hit with my hands. When I'm going my best, I hit completely with my hands. I try not to use my body. But when (the thumb) hurts I basically have to use my body and can't use my hands. We all deal with challenges but this has been the most frustrating one I've dealt with, ever."

Those quotations are alarming, so much so that many fantasy analysts (including myself) advocated shopping Ryan Braun earlier in the season. It’s an injury that seemingly doesn’t have a cure, and it’s simply about maintenance and hoping it heals on its own. When talking about evaluating superstar talent, that’s not an attractive profile whatsoever.

Well, we’re almost midway through August, and Ryan Braun has a .307 TAv. That ranks 31st in all of baseball (min. 300 PA) and is identical to what Adrian Beltre has compiled on the year. It ranks ahead of Nelson Cruz, Hunter Pence, Buster Posey, Ben Zobrist, Daniel Murphy, Anthony Rendon, and Miguel Cabrera.

In short, he’s producing despite the thumb injury. He’s still comfortably a top-20 fantasy outfielder.

Things have changed, though. Braun only has 14 homers this year and his current .209 ISO is almost 50-points below what it was in 2011 and 2012. He’s almost exclusively hitting to center and right fields, too, which is likely a product of his thumb injury. His walk rate has dropped to 6.5 percent, and my personal observation is that he’s being forced to start the bat earlier because he’s not able to be as quick with his hands. This can be seen in his career-high 40.9 percent swing rate at pitches out of the strike zone and his overall 10.7 percent swinging-strike rate, which is markedly higher than his career norms.

Thus, I’m extremely comfortable saying that Ryan Braun has changed as a hitter, and considering the nature of his thumb injury, it’s unclear how long the altered approach will last.

With that said, it’s premature to label Braun as washed up or on the decline. He currently ranks 18th in Major League Baseball in average fly-ball distance (299.17 ft). In addition, his .209 ISO ranks 20th among qualified hitters. The power hasn’t disappeared. Instead, it seems to be a matter of getting to that power. He’s being forced to swing earlier, which is impacting his ability to swing at quality pitches, and his fly-ball rate is down because he’s had such a line-drive approach to center and right field. His 30.8 percent fly-ball rate is a career low, which means he’s not lifting the baseball as often. When he does, it seems everything is business as usual. It’s just not happening as often.

For fantasy owners, if the thumb injuries continue, it seem as if we’re looking at a guy who can hit 20-to-25 homers, hit for high average, and still steal 20 bases. That’s plenty valuable. Only nine players hit 20 homers and stole 20 bags in 2013. However, it’s not the Ryan Braun we remember from 2011 and 2012. More importantly, though, there seems to be this increasing narrative of failure surrounding the 30-year-old outfielder. That’s certainly off the mark, and fantasy owners may be able to get nice value with him next year, if that narrative continues to gain a foothold in the broader baseball consciousness. And if the thumb injury can heal, all bets are off.

2B Robinson Cano, Seattle Mariners
Cano was an interesting case study this offseason. Superstars occasionally change teams, but it rarely affects their fantasy value too dramatically. When it came to Cano moving to Seattle, however, many fantasy owners were straight-up terrified to draft him due to the potential power deflation. I mean, we’re talking about a guy who had hit over .300 in five-consecutive seasons heading into 2014 and had compiled at least 100 runs and/or 100 RBI in five-consecutive seasons. He also had been a playing-time warrior, as he’d played in at least 159 games in every year since 2007.

That’s what you want from a high draft pick. Consistency. Robinson Cano has been the epitome of consistent excellence at the dish, yet some owners were literally taking him off their draft boards.

Could the power really decline that much? He had clobbered at least 25 long balls in five-straight years. Surely that power plays anywhere, right?

It seems the preseason fears were somewhat justified. His current .143 ISO is his worst mark since 2008, and he only has 10 home runs. In fact, PECOTA only projects him to hit 16 homers on the season. That’s absolutely a significant decline in power. It’s no fluke, either. Check out his batted-ball distance:


Avg FB Dist (ft)

MLB Rank
















The 2014 season negatively stands out like a Class-A player getting a spot start in a big-league spring training game. Something has changed. Part of it is certainly the environment. Safeco Park regularly plays below average in power for lefties. Thus, one would expect his power numbers to drop, especially considering the weather in Seattle. I’m particularly interested, though, as to whether Cano has altered his approach to cope with the altered hitting environment. His 51.7 percent ground-ball rate this season is the only time his ground-ball rate has eclipsed 50.0 percent since the 2007 season. So, really, he’s moved to a different park and started hitting the baseball on the ground more often. That’s a prime recipe for decreased power production.

Funny story, though. Robinson Cano is still the third-ranked fantasy second baseman in ESPN leagues and the 18th-ranked overall hitter. The feared power dropoff happened worse than most people predicted, and he’s still an elite hitter. His .323 TAv is 13th-best in all of baseball (min. 300 PA) and is essentially identical to his .324 TAv from a year ago. And, to top it off, he’s running a bit more than he’s done in previous seasons. He’s on pace to break the double-digit steal mark for the first time in his big-league career.

PECOTA projects Cano to finish the season with a .326/.392/.483 slash line, 80 runs, 90 RBI, 16 homers, and 10 stolen bases. Maybe fantasy owners need to adjust to the altered power production, but if anyone thinks that’s not an elite package from an offensive player, they’re delusional. His RBI totals could even benefit from a more consistent one-two punch top the batting order in Austin Jackson and Dustin Ackley, rather than James Jones and Endy Chavez/Brad Miller. Cano is moving back up my fantasy rankings, exactly where he belongs.

J.P. Breen is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see J.P.'s other articles. You can contact J.P. by clicking here

Related Content:  Robinson Cano,  Ryan Braun,  Fantasy

3 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit Lis... (08/13)
<< Previous Column
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Oth... (08/11)
Next Column >>
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Sta... (08/15)
Next Article >>
Premium Article The Call-Up: Rymer Lir... (08/13)

2016 Prospects: Los Angeles Angels Top 10 Pr...
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of November 23-24
Premium Article Raising Aces: Under the Gun 4.0, Part 2
Premium Article The View From Behind The Backstop: My Comple...
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Chris Iannetta As Upgr...
Prospectus Feature: Updates to FRAA, BP's Fi...
Players Prefer Presentation: Baseball Player...

The Lineup Card: Nine Memorable Extra-Inning...
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Tuesday, Augus...
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Royals' Struggling Off...
Premium Article What You Need to Know: August 13, 2014
Fantasy Article Dynasty Dynamics: Our Top 50 Dynasty League ...
Premium Article The Call-Up: Rymer Liriano
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: Wednesday, August 1...

2014-08-21 - Flags Fly Forever Podcast: Ep. 31: J.P.! You...
2014-08-20 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Being Wrong About Yovani ...
2014-08-18 - Fantasy Article The Buyer's Guide: Jonathan Lucroy
2014-08-13 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Setting Expectations on S...
2014-08-11 - Fantasy Article The Buyer's Guide: Josh Harrison
2014-08-11 - Premium Article The Call-Up: Michael Taylor
2014-08-04 - Fantasy Article The Buyer's Guide: Lucas Duda

2014-08-21 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Week 21
2014-08-20 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Being Wrong About Yovani ...
2014-08-15 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Starling Marte and Being ...
2014-08-13 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Setting Expectations on S...
2014-08-11 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Other Competitive Balance...
2014-08-08 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: Jeremy Hellickson
2014-08-07 - Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: A Strategy Example From t...