The Buyer’s Guide: Nick Castellanos

Nick Castellanos began the year being drafted outside the top-15 third baseman, behind guys like Danny Valencia. Almost two months into the season, though, the Tigers’ third baseman is hitting .340/.366/.582 with eight homers and 30 RBI. He’s a top-five fantasy third baseman, according to ESPN’s Player Rater.

However, I think there’s pain coming down the road for Castellanos owners, and not just because he’s sporting a .393 BABIP that’s bound to regress. Everyone can see that. What’s not obvious is that his power surge has been a bit of smoke and mirrors. ESPN’s Home Run Tracker has six of Castellanos’s eight home runs as being “just enough”—or clearing the fence by less than 10 feet. That’s tied for the second most in all of baseball, with Boston’s Mookie Betts checking in at number one.

In some ways, that’s unsurprising. Castellanos didn’t suddenly transform from a 10-15 home run hitter—as he’s been in the past couple of years—to a 20-plus beast at the hot corner. It might happen this year due to his monstrous start, but fantasy owners shouldn’t be expecting his sudden uptick in homers to continue. His average batted-ball velocity is 89.0 mph, which is rather pedestrian and is tied with Johnny Giavotella. So, no, Castellanos isn’t backing up his surprise power surge with analytics that suggest he’s mashing the cover off the baseball.

At the most, one could say that Castellanos has lowered his ground-ball rate to 28.2 percent, which is giving him more chances to hit homers. It’s interesting that he’s hitting for such a high batting average with that high fly-ball rate, though, especially with a strikeout rate at 22 percent.

The 24-year-old can hang his hat on his success against sliders this season, something that has historically given him fits.

That improvement is one of the biggest reasons why Castellanos has burst onto the stage this year. It extends to curveballs, as he’s hitting .462 this year on curveballs he’s put into play. That greater success against breaking balls has seemingly translated into more confidence, as he’s swinging more than he ever has against breaking pitches.

I’m not sure that’s particularly sustainable or predictive of future success; however, it is a big part of what Castellanos has done well in 2016. He’s crushed breaking pitches—both for average and for power—which has closed one of the major holes in his swing. He’s still only hitting .143 at pitches in the low-outside corner of the strike zone. But showing an ability to capitalize on bad sliders and curveballs has been huge for Castellanos, as pitchers can’t consistently locate in that low-outside corner all game. They’ll eventually miss, and the young man has punished those mistakes.

I still believe that Castellanos has the potential to be a better real-life player than a fantasy player. By that, I think he’ll hit .270 with 12-15 homers, on average, and that’s just not all that valuable in the standard fantasy league. It’s fine in today’s run environment, though, and can be attractive at, or near, the league minimum. Unfortunately for the Tigers, he’ll need to improve with the glove to be a truly quality option at third base, and that’s a tall task.

BUYER’S ADVICE: SELL

Castellanos owners must be brave and not get lulled to sleep by a crazy strong month-and-a-half. There are plenty of signs that this power surge is not sustainable over the course of the year, nor should it be expected to occur again next year. I think he’ll hit for more average than he has in the past, but I’d be surprised to see the 24-year-old reach the 20-homer plateau more than once or twice in his career. Something will have to have drastically changed in his approach and his swing for that to happen. It’s best to sell while the gettin’ is good.