Welcome to the blog for "The Untitled Joe Sheehan Book," which will presumably have a catchier title at some point. In this space I’ll chronicle the process of writing my first solo book, which should be out just in time for you to enjoy on an off-day during the World Series. The idea for a blog like this is, to some extent, stolen from the great Joe Posnanski, who started The Soul of Baseball blog while he was working on his wonderful biography, with the same name, of Buck O’Neil.
Since we announced "The Untitled Joe Sheehan Book" a month ago, I’ve spent most of my time reading what I’ve written over the past decade for Baseball Prospectus, trying to pare about 1,500 pieces down to a couple dozen for inclusion in the book. Those pieces are going to form the framework of the book, serving as both a "best of" for longtime readers and an introduction for new ones. Make no mistake about it; as much as I want the people who have read BP for years to buy the book, I want to be able to reach beyond that group as well. I want all baseball fans to be able to pick up the book and enjoy it even if they’ve never heard of BP.
The book isn’t going to just be a collection, however. I’m looking for columns—mostly my "Daily Prospectus" and "Prospectus Today" work, but also material under other headers—that serve as launch points for additional discussion. In the same way that this blog borrows from Posnanski, the book itself does from Bill Simmons’ first, Now I Can Die In Peace, which collected Simmons’ writing on his beloved Boston Red Sox in the aftermath of their 2004 championship, and included substantial original material. I doubt I will use the footnotes conceit that Simmons employed, but the idea—to use the old as a springboard for the new—stems from that tome.
Right now, I have a request. If you have enjoyed my work, take a second to think about any pieces that you might like to see in the book. I have created my own list, which I will work with Christina Kahrl to pare down, but I want to know what the readers think should be included. I want to know if I’ve missed something, if perhaps I’ve written something that you want to see expanded upon in this book. This book didn’t even exist as an idea three months ago, and it’s changed in my own mind a half-dozen times since Dave Pease and I first talked about it; I am certain that it can only be better the more feedback I get on the idea, the process and the execution.
That’s what the blog is about: documenting the process of writing this book and using whatever feedback is generated to make it better.
I’m going to be honest here: I’m terrified. There have been days in my career when the idea of writing a thousand words was daunting; I’ve signed on to write 100,000. Writing a book other than the annual—a process I loved, even when it nearly killed me—has never been a priority, despite it being one of the things you’re "supposed" to do as a writer. It took the right idea at the right time to even get me interested, and even with that I feel like I’m free-falling a bit. So I suppose this blog will also document the trepidation, even fear, as well, as I take on this new challenge.
I know that I’ll enjoy it more if you take it with me. Thanks, and let’s get started.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.
Subscribe now
I would love to see stuff like this expanded upon in the book. http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=9566
The article about Bochy's misuse of Frew Lewis I think is a great depiction of how few managers know how to use their talent. Something that seems like such a simple concept to a BP reader, is missed by a man making 7 digits to get the most out of his talent.
"There's no mystery here. The reason for the disparity is because Colon was credited with 21 wins, while Santana did everything a pitcher can do better than Colon did."
"It's not just that Colon finished ahead of Santana. It's the gap between the two. If 25 of 28 voters can't identify the best pitcher in the league, what are we doing? What, exactly, is getting through to the electorate?"
"Johan Santana got shafted, and instead of making history as a back-to-back award winner, instead becomes just another data point in the argument for remaking the coverage of major-league baseball."
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=4594
Consider this for your book, Joe, if only to educate those that still dismiss sabermetrics as some parents' basement alchemy that solely exists for self-serving Computer Geeks That Don't Watch The Games.
Greinke, Lincecum, and many more future Cy Young winners and baseball fans will thank you.
I vote for your "Prospectus Today" written after Game 5 of the 2004 ALCS. In the ensuing years the mythology of that series has clouded the actual events, and the subtleties of what happened have been forgotten. People don't remember how awful Joe Torre, the Yankee rotation, defense were, and you pierced the myth of "Derek Jeter Postseason God" You also touched on a great, yet forgotten NLCS.
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=3571
(Tongue in cheek: after all, no one's written about the 2004 Red Sox, right?)
Just spent half an hour reviewing all of the 2004 ALCS columns. Compelling story, well written articles, and a treasure trove of analytics that could serve to frame a number of different sabermetric discussions. And the added joy of remembering that Joe West has been a grandstanding boob for a really long time.
From my studies (and a bit of practice), it is in some ways easier to write a book than it is to write a column (or in my case, a short story). The extra amount of words you have in a novel give you time to flesh out your ideas. Yet in a column, you often have word count or page limits which can cause people to be vague or sound "rushed".
In any event, glad you're still around and working with BP.
I will think about my favorite columns, but my favorite quotes are from chats (I think). I give you credit for both, but I could be wrong in that ascription:
The first is from a long time ago, in which you first suggested wagering on the frequency of the phrase "past a diving Jeter." I don't care how much his defense has improved, I still think of this anytime Jeter's defense is even mentioned.
The second is from last fall in which you started a chat by referencing Tim McCarver and saying "The thing about Joe Sheehan's chats is that they start on time." It was perfect.
Joe on bullpen management
Joe on pitching to the score and other urban myths
etc
It seems having read Joe's work for a couple of years that themes could be identified and pieces linked by Joe's narrative
May I also humbly suggest a title:
The 12 Commandments of Joe Sheehan: 12 ways to make baseball a better game
Something along those lines would be cool in my opinion
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=5551
A week later (Greatest show on Earth,10/16/03), after several other well-documented critical game-management mistakes (by you, anyway - the mainstream media somehow missed it), you said "The Cubs will never again get this close with Baker as the manager". Right again.
The Colon-Santana piece is a must.
I would for sure pick your column on the last game at Yankee Stadium from the end of 2008. One of my favorites by far.
Also, I'd love to see an "evolution" chapter that details your take on roster value throughout your career at BP. I remember around 2004 or so when you started taking a different stance on the value of defense. One of my favorite parts of your writing was that it seemed like you were learning with us, not just preaching to us. You'd pick something up, point it out, then return to it a few months later, and slowly build a case for or against.
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=4963
http://baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=4969
Also your magnificent post-mortem on the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox in August 2006:
http://baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=5444
Can't wait to read the book....
---Keith R.A. DeCandido
Suggested theme for at least one segment: Demystifying the Field Manager, the advent of the Bench Coach, and the perennnial categories of Dreadful Field Management. Go, Joe!
:D
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=2431
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=829
This series on the Series is what made me the loyal BP reader that I have been since then.